Cole HaanMen's Lenox Hill Split Toe Oxford

Replaced my old pair with a new pair. Great, good fitting, & nice-looking shoes.

This is a very nice show for daily business wear, when you don't feel like a cap toe Oxford.It felt good from the get-go, except for a slight stiffness at the ankle which improved after two or three wearings.These shoes leave my feet feeling comfortable after eight hours of wear.All in all, I'm very satisfied.

These Cole Haan shoes are great fitting and very comfortable, perfect dress shoe. Definitely would buy again. Wish they were made in USA, but at least not in the PRC (actually Vietnam).

First, this is not my first pair of Cole Haan shoes but it is the first time I purchased them through Amazon. The shoes came in a timely manner (as expected) and they fit extremely well. They are actually replacing Cole Haan shoes that I've worn out. Since I've only worn the new ones a few times, I'm not sure if they have a break in period. However, this pair of shoes do not have the same Nike comfort cushion insoles my previous pair had so they are more firm. I'm very pleased with the look, the fit and everything about the shoe but will miss the more comfortable cushion inside. Cole Haan shoe quality is definitely still very good and I will probably get another pair in a different style and color through Amazon when I purchase again. The only reason I did not give a 5 star is because I had such a comfortable prior pair of Cole Haans and that set a very high expectation for the new ones. No complaints, just fell one star short from my expected experience.

I've been buying Cole Haan shoes for work for about 20 years. The last ten years or so I've primarily bought Calhouns, but have bought a few others as well. These are not as shiny as Calhouns and run about a half size less wide than Calhouns for the same measurement. I like these and would buy them again, but would go a bit wider on the size. My feet are wide, so if yours are the same then go higher than Medium width. The leather in these shoes also does not crease to the same extent as Calhouns. I never had toe separation issues with Calhouns, and they lasted a long time with no problems. I had them re-soled and re-heeled by both Cole Haan and by a local shoe repair shop. Both worked great although the shoe shop was cheaper. I've owned other Cole Haan shoes in the past that are similar to the Lenox Hill and did have toe separation problems after a year or two of regular use. If these separate then I'll update my review.

My husband hates to shop, so I bought these stylish yet comfortable shoes online. I simply bought the same size as his old Cole Haans. He loves them but remarked they were tighter than his previous pair. He's hoping they'll stretch out once he breaks them in. He likes that they're dressy enough for the office yet the sole is more durable with rubber inset treads in the leather. So that the sole has good traction but doesn't look like hiking boots or a thick 'walking shoe' sole.

This looks like a used shoe. Shows damages too. Disappointed.

A very classy shoe! He says they need to be broken in some but overall he's been really happy with his new shoes! He is in a for every day so they are definitely getting their fair share of wear and tear! Great buy!